Growing up in my family, money was like the weather: we had good months and bad months, with the pace of the seasons set by how well dad’s business was doing at that time of year.
He was the only breadwinner and payer of bills, while mum had to think about all the rest: groceries, errands, kids. All very traditional, all very Italian countryside.
My brother and I didn’t particularly feel the bad months: the worst that could happen was being fed the supermarket brand of chocolate for a few weeks, perhaps a belated birthday present or a less flashy Christmas, which was then made back and then some the following year. It didn’t matter, at least not to us.
It did matter a lot to my dad, who had assumed the role of “the provider”, as his father had before him and as his two older brothers did as well. By tying your self-worth to your earnings, what happens to your self-esteem when you feel you’re not delivering as well as you’d like?
When money was tight, it was always mum who told us when we needed to “tighten our belts”: dad would become even more silent than he normally was.
In a 2024 poll cited by Sarah Coles, head of personal finance at AJ Bell, only 15% of men surveyed agreed with the phrase: “Expenses are a man’s responsibility, even if his wife can help him”. However, when asked what their community thought, almost 45% said most other people would agree with the statement.
This is usually interpreted to mean that men can feel the weight of other people’s expectations that they ought to “provide”, which can hold them back from asking questions, seeking help, or, in the case of my dad, simply mentioning money (let alone talking about it).
On paper, men have little to complain about when money is concerned. HMRC data shows they hold 59% of all Stocks and Shares ISAs, DWP data shows men in their late 50s have an average of £156,000 in their pension against £81,000 for women and among full-time workers, men earn 6.8% more on average, Coles said.
But these numbers may make you feel even worse about yourself if you think you are not keeping up with something every man is supposedly born knowing how to do. A modern repercussion of this way of understanding manhood and money is the obsession with wealth and luxury that some young men are falling into, as I previously discussed.
Feeling that you should already be a money expert is the first of five financial traps that men are more exposed to, according to Coles.
Yet financial education in schools “isn’t universally good”, she said, so “nobody needs to feel any embarrassment about not understanding something they’ve never been taught”.
Another risk is getting money tied up with masculinity. In an experiment by Dan Cassino, professor of government and politics at Fairleigh Dickinson University and author of Bitcoin Bros: Masculinity, Cryptocurrency and the Future of Men, the researcher found that men who were less confident in their masculinity took a risky bet over a safe sum 50.2% of the time, against 47.9% for other men. He concluded that some of these men may be using investment risk to perform their masculinity, including in assets such as cryptocurrency.
For Coles, “the more people understand about investment, the less it runs the risk of getting mixed up with other psychological drivers, because the easier it is to test whether the risk level is right for your overall portfolio”.
Another problem men can face is confidence growing faster than knowledge. When the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) asked people to assess their own financial capability, 20% of women rated themselves as low, against 14% of men.
Behavioural finance also shows that male investors trade on average more than women and take risks that do not improve their returns, which researchers put down to over-confidence, said Coles.
The fourth trap is taking on too many financial commitments. Given the chance, men choose competitive environments more than women, which risks spilling over into competition on lifestyle and status symbols.
Here, her practical fixes were to know how much cash is available each month, with one of the many free budgeting apps to keep track, and quit social media accounts that show off glitzy lifestyles.
Finally, the last trap for men is waiting too long to get help. The sooner someone asks, the smaller the problem and the easier it is to solve, Coles said. Some men find that too hard because society expects them to be good with money, so there is shame when things go wrong.
But, she continued, “given the fact we’re all human and we all make mistakes, there will be times in our life when our finances aren’t pretty”.
Once you have done all you can, perhaps accepting chance, cycles and your own fallibility might be the first step to shake yourself out of the “provider-role” trap and take money as it comes, like the weather.
Your kids won’t know they’re eating supermarket chocolate until they turn 30 anyway.