Connecting: 216.73.216.23
Forwarded: 216.73.216.23, 162.159.114.53:43923
Benchmark shruggers: UK funds that ignore the index suffer | Trustnet Skip to the content

Benchmark shruggers: UK funds that ignore the index suffer

17 November 2026

All five funds whose benchmark explained less than 40% of their performance lagged it over three years, by up to 59.6 percentage points.

By Matteo Anelli

Deputy editor, Trustnet

Straying from the index has not paid off in the IA UK All Companies sector – at least not for the five funds that moved least in step with their benchmark over three years.

All five funds below finished behind their respective benchmarks by between 23.7 and 59.6 percentage points, Trustnet research has found, suggesting a difficult three years for the five active managers.

In the previous IA Global instalment of this series, only one of the 18 benchmark shruggers beat the MSCI AC World over three years. In the UK, none managed it.

To qualify to feature in this study, a fund needed an R-squared below 0.4 over the three years to 30 September 2026, meaning its benchmark explained less than 40% of its movements.

All five names also had an annualised tracking error of at least 8.9%, meaning their returns typically strayed that far from the benchmark each year (full methodology below). Excess return, or the gap between the fund’s three-year return and its benchmark’s, is highlighted as well.

UK All Companies funds with lowest R-squared over 3yrs

Fund

Benchmark

Benchmark return

R²

Tracking error

Excess return (pp)

Liontrust UK Ethical

MSCI UK

54.4%

0.31

11.7%

−23.7

FP Octopus UK Future Generations

FTSE All Share

53.9%

0.32

10.1%

−30.4

VT Sorbus Vector

MSCI UK IMI

53.5%

0.35

8.9%

−44.5

Consistent Opportunities Unit Trust

FTSE All Share

53.9%

0.37

13.2%

−33.3

WS Lindsell Train UK Equity

FTSE All Share

53.9%

0.37

9.7%

−59.6

Source: FinXL

The formerly popular, quality-focused WS Lindsell Train UK Equity fund trailed the FTSE All Share by 59.6 percentage points – the largest shortfall in the screen.

The fund was last of 201 funds in the IA UK All Companies sector in 2025, losing 7.2% when the sector returned 15.4% and the FTSE All Share rose 24%. It ranked 187th of 197 in 2024, with 2.4% against 9.5% for the index, and 162nd of 195 in 2023, with 4.7% against 7.9%.

These disappointing years followed a very successful long-term track record in the 2010s and there could be signs of a recovery as last month the fund rose 10.8% as quality stocks rebounded. This was manager Nick Train’s best month ever. However, experts suggested it is too early to say whether this feat can be sustained.

The most different fund on the list from its benchmark was Liontrust UK Ethical, which had the lowest R-squared of the five and second-largest tracking error. Despite this, it lost the least ground to its benchmark, trailing the MSCI United Kingdom index by 23.7 percentage points.

Peter Michaelis and Simon Clements run the £334.9m fund using Liontrust’s Sustainable Future process, which looks for companies positioned to benefit from structural growth trends. It holds 33 stocks and has an active share of 85.2%, meaning that share of the portfolio differs from the index.

Financials make up 36.7% of the portfolio, industrials 23.9% and technology 14.3%, against 0.9% for technology in its comparator. Top holdings included NatWest (5.9%), Compass Group (4.7%) and Admiral (4.6%), with its largest underweights HSBC (11.1 percentage points), Shell (8.9) and AstraZeneca (8.0).

Elsewhere, FP Octopus UK Future Generations is run by Dominic Weller, who invests in companies aligned with three themes: building a sustainable planet, empowering people and revitalising healthcare.

Also named above were VT Sorbus Vector, a high-conviction, buy-and-hold portfolio leaning towards small and mid-caps; and the Consistent Opportunities fund, managed by Nick Pritchard, who takes a bottom-up approach, looking for quality companies in under-covered parts of the market.

Three other funds just outside the scope of the study based on their R-squared were also worthy of mention. Managed by the same team as the Liontrust fund above, Liontrust Sustainable Future UK Growth was one such example.

IA UK All Companies funds with R-squared below 0.5% over 3yrs

Fund

Benchmark

Benchmark return

R²

Tracking error

Excess return (pp)

Liontrust Sustainable Future UK Growth

MSCI UK

54.4%

0.43

9.9%

−19.8

Baillie Gifford UK Equity Alpha

FTSE All Share

53.9%

0.48

10%

−27.0

IFSL Marlborough Multi-Cap Growth

FTSE All Share

53.9%

0.49

11.2%

−20.7

Source: FinXL

Launched in 2001, Liontrust Sustainable Future UK Growth targets a tracking error of 7% and leans towards growth by holding more medium-sized and smaller companies than the index. The focus is on sustainability and companies that provide solutions to, or will benefit from, longer-term themes, according to RSMR analysts.

“This is not a traditional ethical fund, although it will avoid sectors such as tobacco,” they said. “The fund represents a good option for responsible investors looking for UK equity exposure who are willing to accept equity volatility risk.”

IFSL Marlborough Multi-Cap Growth is run by FE fundinfo Alpha Manager Richard Hallett and, while diversified against the domestic market, it was highlighted on Trustnet as one of the six IA UK All Companies funds most correlated to the S&P 500, as well as the active funds hit with heavier losses than passives in last year’s market downturn.

Baillie Gifford UK Equity Alpha also had an R-squared below 0.5.

 

Previously in this series, we also covered the IA Global funds that stayed closest to their benchmarks.

 

Methodology

Using FinXL, we analysed active funds in the sector. All data points were calculated from 36 monthly returns over the three years to 30 September 2026, measured against each fund’s own stated benchmark.

For the returns pattern against the benchmark, we used R-squared, which measures how much of a fund’s performance is explained by movements in its benchmark on a range from 0 to 1.

We then measured how far the divergence went using annualised tracking error, which measures how far a fund’s returns typically deviated from its benchmark.

Because a fund can have a low R-squared but a modest tracking error if it is simply less volatile than its benchmark or a high tracking error but a high R-squared if it amplifies the index’s movements, we combined the two ratios together, identifying funds that are independent of their benchmark in pattern as well as in magnitude.

For the definition of a ‘benchmark shrugger’, we used an R-squared below 0.4, and all funds meeting this threshold also had a tracking error above 9%.

Funds without a recorded benchmark or a full three-year track record were excluded. Returns are three-year total returns in sterling to 30 September 2026 net of fees.

A low R-squared shows that a fund behaves differently from its benchmark; it does not, on its own, indicate whether that has been good or bad for investors.

Editor's Picks

Loading...

Data provided by FE fundinfo. Care has been taken to ensure that the information is correct, but FE fundinfo neither warrants, represents nor guarantees the contents of information, nor does it accept any responsibility for errors, inaccuracies, omissions or any inconsistencies herein. Past performance does not predict future performance, it should not be the main or sole reason for making an investment decision. The value of investments and any income from them can fall as well as rise.