FE Alpha Manager Hugh Young’s Asia Pacific funds are the latest high-profile portfolios facing soft-closure in the coming months.
The likes of First State Asia Pacific
are already closed to new money, and it was revealed last summer that the First State Asia Pacific Leaders
fund was also moving to slow inflows in anticipation of a soft-closure.
In the firm’s latest trading statement, Aberdeen revealed it has witnessed net inflows of £4.4bn in the last six months, which includes the five crown-rated Aberdeen Asia Pacific
fund and four crown-rated Aberdeen Global Asia Pacific Equity
Chief executive of Aberdeen Martin Gilbert confirmed that the group is likely to go down the same path for its Asia Pacific range as it has done for its emerging markets range, which has seen a number of soft-closures in recent months.
In March, the flagship Aberdeen Emerging Markets
fund upped its initial charge to 2 per cent, in an attempt to stem demand.
In anticipation of a soft-closure, FE Trustnet
highlights three funds that could act as alternatives to the Aberdeen Asia Pacific portfolio:
Edinburgh Dragon Trust
Rowan Dartington’s Tim Cockerill believes investors may have to go out of their comfort zone to find a viable alternative to the Aberdeen fund.
"Investors have got a big problem – not just in the Asia Pacific sector, but in the emerging markets sector," he said.
"When it comes to this kind of fund, I want something that has experienced guys in charge, that I don’t have to worry about, which is what Aberdeen and First State offer."
"It’s difficult to see where you can now go if you want something like this."
Cockerill says investment trusts run by one of the two groups are good options. He says the obvious closed-ended alternative is one of the trusts Young (pictured)
The £666m Edinburgh Dragon Trust has similar holdings to Aberdeen Asia Pacific
, but its smaller size means that it is a little more nimble, allowing it to hold a greater number of small and mid cap companies.
The fact it is closed-ended means there is no chance of the portfolio being adversely impacted by inflows, and so it is likely to remain more flexible for the foreseeable future.
Both the fund and trust's top-two holdings are the same – Samsung and Overseas Chinese Banking Group – and there is significant overlap through the rest of the portfolio’s top-10.
Edinburgh Dragon IT is slightly more concentrated and, unlike Aberdeen Asia Pacific, gets its exposure to India via the Aberdeen Global Indian Equity
In spite of the overlap, lower charges and effective gearing have helped the trust outpace its open-ended counterpart significantly over one, three, five and 10 years.
Performance of fund vs trust and index over 10yrs
Source: FE Analytics
||1yr returns (%)
|3yr returns (%)
||5yr returns (%)
||10yr returns (%)
|Edinburgh Dragon Trust
|Aberdeen Asia Pacific
|MSCI AC Asia Pacific ex Japan
The trust has easily beaten its MSCI Asia Pacific ex Japan benchmark over all of these periods.
Edinburgh Dragon Trust has a better record than the Aberdeen Asia Pacific fund during falling markets, meaning that investors can expect a similar attention to downside protection, which has come to characterise Young’s style.
The trust has an ongoing charges figure (OCF) of 1.27 per cent and does not charge a performance fee. By contrast, Aberdeen Asia Pacific has an OCF of 1.84 per cent. It is on a discount of 5.7 per cent and is currently 10 per cent geared.
Young and his team also run the Aberdeen New Dawn IT
– another emerging Asia trust, which is on a discount of 5.9 per cent.
It has similar holdings to both Aberdeen Asia Pacific and the Edinburgh Dragon Trust, though is more concentrated than both.
Pacific Assets IT
"Pacific Assets IT is another one, which has been run by First State for a number of years," said Cockerill.
"It’s on a slightly higher discount [then the Edinburgh Dragon Trust], which is important. If these trusts go on to premiums, they may as well be soft-closed because you’re paying so much more for them."
According to the AIC, the Pacific Assets IT is on a discount of 8.4 per cent.
The £191m trust is headed up by FE Alpha Manager David Gait
and Stuart Paul
. It has significantly underperformed Young’s trusts and fund over five and 10 years, but comes out on top over one and three years.
Performance of trust, fund and index over 3yrs
Source: FE Analytics
As with all of First State’s portfolios, the managers target quality, solid companies that have sustainable business models over the long-term. It has been consistently less volatile than the Edinburgh Dragon Trust in recent years.
Gait and Paul's biggest regional weighting overall is to India, at 19 per cent. This compares with 12.8 per cent for Edinburgh Dragon Trust.
The pair are significantly underweight China, with just 2.8 per cent invested directly in the country.
The Pacific Assets IT has an OCF of 1.27 per cent and charges a performance fee of 15 per cent every year. It currently has no gearing.
Schroder Asian Alpha Plus
FE Research believes Matthew Dobbs’
five crown-rated fund has the core principles required when picking a portfolio of this type, but points out that the manager’s high-conviction style means it is more susceptible to big losses during falling markets.
"The fund benefits from the established analyst team settled in the Asia Pacific, which provides easy access to companies’ managers thanks to Schroders’ strong reputation," the team said.
"The fact that businesses are scrutinised from a corporate governance angle is encouraging, as is the in-house assessment of how they treat shareholders. This fund has the ability to diversify a portfolio and would sit well in a core/satellite strategy, therefore."
"However, the fund holds fewer companies than its benchmark that offer more predictable and stable earnings, which may penalise it if markets fall again."
The Schroder Asian Alpha Plus fund has beaten its Aberdeen rival since its launch in November 2007, but has been more volatile along the way.
Performance of funds vs sector and index since Nov 2007
Source: FE Analytics
It uses a different benchmark – the MSCI Far East ex Japan index – which it has also beaten over the period.
Dobbs' biggest regional position by far is Hong Kong, which has a 26 per cent weighting. This is generally an indirect play on China, which only has an 8 per cent weighting.
Schroder Asian Alpha Plus requires a minimum investment of £1,000 and has an OCF of 1.7 per cent. It is £492m in size.