Skip to the content

Why discount Japan offers compelling value

26 February 2020

Joël Le Saux, portfolio manager of the Syz Asset Management's OYSTER Japan Opportunities fund, on why investors should start looking to Japan for opportunities as it begins to recover from decades of deflationary despondency.

By Joël Le Saux,

Syz Asset Management

Following decades of deflationary despondency, the Japanese economy is springing back to life. Yet foreign investors continue to under-allocate, creating a discount to other developed markets. The Topix is trading at a price-to-earnings multiple in line with its seven-year average, and significantly beneath that of both the US and Europe. The question is: will this trend reverse in 2020?

Despite stubborn negative market sentiment, the underlying dynamics of the world’s fourth largest economy have created a fertile bed for equity investors.

Below, I explain the reasons Japan valuations have been suppressed and discuss why the archipelago offers investors compelling long-term value in 2020.

 

Tax hike fears overblown

The latest consumption tax hike was delayed due to fears it would negatively impact consumption, before finally being implemented in October of 2019. However, the enactment was successful, with minimal impact to the economy, no changes in consumption patterns and more importantly, no return into deflation.

This was partly due to preventative measures, which exempted food products from the tax, and partly due to the robustness of the economy, with jobless rates at multi-decade lows and wages rising. The number of train users – the best measure for the health of the Japanese economy – is still increasing and GDP growth for Q3 surpassed expectations.

 

Savings culture lowers vol

Perhaps negative investor sentiment surrounding Japan can be explained by low consumer confidence numbers. At ten-year lows, the figures are a reminder of scars from the past. Due to decades of deflation, the Japanese have become staunch savers. While wages increased by 2 per cent per year over the past five years, consumption only rose by half, compromising the Bank of Japan’s intentions to spur inflation.

However, on the positive side, consistent low spending ensures minimal volatility for investors in periods of economic stagnation. Also compensating for the lack of consumption, the service sector has increased dramatically over the past two decades – now representing three times the manufacturing sector in terms of profit.

 

Bank of Japan dialling back stimulus

Also known as the great market manipulator, the Bank of Japan owns approximately 8 per cent of the Japanese stock market and has been consistently intervening in the bond market as part of its multi-trillion-yen stimulus programme. This has led some foreign investors to worry the Bank’s intervention is distorting liquidity and prices in the market.

Signs the Bank of Japan may now be poised to dial back stimulus have comforted foreign investors. Nevertheless, these investors must appreciate the central bank’s assurance it will intervene if markets drop, which provides an element of safety to investing in Japan.

Another unexpected buyer supported the market in 2019 – companies themselves, through buybacks. Share repurchase programmes increased, enhancing return on equity despite overall flat earnings growth.

 

Constructive earnings growth

The 2019 earnings season in Japan saw downward revisions in consensus earnings estimates for this year, with unchanged earnings vs 2018. However, earnings growth for this year remains constructive at 5-7 per cent.

Although this is considerably less than 2018’s 8 per cent, the market seems to have digested the lower earnings growth environment, which leaves less room for disappointment. Across the developed world, companies will find it hard to grow faster than GDP, and Japan will not be alone in this predicament.

 

Joël Le Saux is portfolio manager of the OYSTER Japan Opportunities at Syz Asset Management. The views expressed above are his own and should not be taken as investment advice.

Editor's Picks

Loading...

Videos from BNY Mellon Investment Management

Loading...

Data provided by FE fundinfo. Care has been taken to ensure that the information is correct, but FE fundinfo neither warrants, represents nor guarantees the contents of information, nor does it accept any responsibility for errors, inaccuracies, omissions or any inconsistencies herein. Past performance does not predict future performance, it should not be the main or sole reason for making an investment decision. The value of investments and any income from them can fall as well as rise.