Run on European banks now a real possibility, say experts
18 May 2012
Greeks have withdrawn around €3bn in the past 11 days and there are fears that similar panic could soon grip Spain.
Bank runs and a chain reaction collapse of the euro system are now real possibilities after Moody’s overnight decision to downgrade 16 Spanish banks, according to Jason Gaywood, director at currency specialist HiFX.
Another ratings agency, Fitch, downgraded Greece even further into junk status, warning of the possibility of widespread public and private default in the country.
"This simply cannot continue indefinitely and sooner or later either the money or the will to artificially support these institutions and sovereign nations alike will run out and one gets the feeling that it is now a matter of when rather than if we will witness the break-up of the crippled euro," Gaywood said.
He believes the threat of bank runs on Spanish lenders, once added to the burden of huge property debts that look unlikely to be repaid, could push the country into an irretrievable spiral resulting in either bank collapses or mass bailouts.
"The danger now is that panic will set in as the population races to get their money out, resulting in the self-fulfilling prophecy of a run on the banks. We witnessed this situation here in the UK back in 2008 when people queued for hours to withdraw cash from the doomed Northern Rock. The difference now is that a large number of banks and nations are affected and the risk of contagion is acute," he added.
Tristan Cooper, sovereign debt analyst at Fidelity Worldwide Investment, says the ECB is coming under increasing pressure to intervene.
"With rumours of bank deposit withdrawals, Spain can ill-afford another blow to confidence. Once a bank run begins it is very hard to stop without a credible deposit guarantee," he explained.
"As Greece shuffles towards the exit, all eyes are turning to the ECB. Recent experience of political dithering indicates that this is the only European institution capable of erecting a truly credible firewall."
However, Cooper believes the ECB is likely to suffer internal political divisions as the situation becomes more severe, making it harder to find the consensus necessary for the action required.
Andrey Dirgin, head of research at Forex Club, thinks a Greek exit from the eurozone could be worse than many analysts believe, and that a new round of downgrades would be likely to follow.
"The stability of the eurozone would be fundamentally undermined and we would expect the positions of the common currency to be slashed," he said.
Dirgin thinks the turmoil will also affect the UK, with markets fearing that Britain will be dragged down by problems in its biggest trading partner.
Another ratings agency, Fitch, downgraded Greece even further into junk status, warning of the possibility of widespread public and private default in the country.
"This simply cannot continue indefinitely and sooner or later either the money or the will to artificially support these institutions and sovereign nations alike will run out and one gets the feeling that it is now a matter of when rather than if we will witness the break-up of the crippled euro," Gaywood said.
He believes the threat of bank runs on Spanish lenders, once added to the burden of huge property debts that look unlikely to be repaid, could push the country into an irretrievable spiral resulting in either bank collapses or mass bailouts.
"The danger now is that panic will set in as the population races to get their money out, resulting in the self-fulfilling prophecy of a run on the banks. We witnessed this situation here in the UK back in 2008 when people queued for hours to withdraw cash from the doomed Northern Rock. The difference now is that a large number of banks and nations are affected and the risk of contagion is acute," he added.
Tristan Cooper, sovereign debt analyst at Fidelity Worldwide Investment, says the ECB is coming under increasing pressure to intervene.
"With rumours of bank deposit withdrawals, Spain can ill-afford another blow to confidence. Once a bank run begins it is very hard to stop without a credible deposit guarantee," he explained.
"As Greece shuffles towards the exit, all eyes are turning to the ECB. Recent experience of political dithering indicates that this is the only European institution capable of erecting a truly credible firewall."
However, Cooper believes the ECB is likely to suffer internal political divisions as the situation becomes more severe, making it harder to find the consensus necessary for the action required.
Andrey Dirgin, head of research at Forex Club, thinks a Greek exit from the eurozone could be worse than many analysts believe, and that a new round of downgrades would be likely to follow.
"The stability of the eurozone would be fundamentally undermined and we would expect the positions of the common currency to be slashed," he said.
Dirgin thinks the turmoil will also affect the UK, with markets fearing that Britain will be dragged down by problems in its biggest trading partner.
More Headlines
-
‘The most disappointing few years': Lindsell Train UK Equity's 108-month top-quartile streak ends
05 September 2025
-
The stocks being added to your FTSE 100 and FTSE 250 trackers
04 September 2025
-
Why investors should focus on the Rise of Humanoid Robots
04 September 2025
-
The cheapest platform to buy funds, shares and a mix of both
04 September 2025
-
Investors flee equities as stock markets reach record highs
04 September 2025
Editor's Picks
Loading...
Videos from BNY Mellon Investment Management
Loading...
Data provided by FE fundinfo. Care has been taken to ensure that the information is correct, but FE fundinfo neither warrants, represents nor guarantees the contents of information, nor does it accept any responsibility for errors, inaccuracies, omissions or any inconsistencies herein. Past performance does not predict future performance, it should not be the main or sole reason for making an investment decision. The value of investments and any income from them can fall as well as rise.